Back and Next

Found Missing
In Short
Function Junction
Plugged In
Filling in the Blanks
Food Pharmacy
Spring 2000
Running in the family
      --Barbara Seaman
When Donna Cantor and her sister crossed the finish line together at the Toronto marathon in the fall of 1998, neither was running.

In fact, only Donna had started the race five hours and 50 minutes earlier.

So how did the two sisters end up in an impromptu joint venture? The answer has all the makings of a classic tale of CPT deficiency

Donna wasn’t into sports much through high school, but her younger sister Aviva was. Growing up, Donna remembers meeting Aviva at the bus after athletic events. “Many times I’d pick her up off the street and carry her home,” says Donna with a wry smile.

Eventually, Aviva’s frequent bouts of muscle symptoms led to a diagnosis of CPT deficiency. Meanwhile Donna began running on her own while at university. “After I accomplished my first 10K, I upped the ante and aimed for a half marathon. When I’d done two of those, I thought, well, I might as well try a marathon.”

Donna began training with a running group four to five times a week, sometimes running for as long as three hours. But she was always lagging behind, even though the other runners were older and heavier. “There were times when I’d be really sick and have black urine,” says Donna. “But I just thought I had to train harder.”

Come marathon day in October, Donna rode the four hours from Ottawa to Toronto with her family and joined the other runners at the starting line. Half way through the race she still felt pretty good. But somewhere around 30 kilometers, her legs began seizing up. Soon wrenching cramps spread like a plague through her body.

Donna geared down to a walk, then a near crawl: Two steps, stop, stretch, two steps, stop, stretch. “I was crying at that point,” recalls Donna. “I was going so slow.”

When she still had 2 kilometers left, Aviva came looking for her. “My sister understands what it’s like to want to do something and not be able to,” says Donna. “So she didn’t tell me to quit.” Instead Aviva held Donna’s arm and walked beside her: two steps, stop, stretch, two more, stop, stretch….

One kilometer from the finish line, Donna could see her family and friends waving and cheering, even though the officials had already picked up the pylons. “The race was over,” says Donna, “but I still had my arms out, reaching for trees or whatever would hold me up. Everyone was crying when I crossed the finish line—they could see how much agony I was in. I remember someone saying, ‘Well, you still ran a marathon.’ Then they put a medal over my head.”

Immediately, paramedics whisked her off to the first aid tent where she joined a few other exhausted runners who were getting intravenous glucose. But while the other athletes soon hopped up, rejuvenated, Donna began shaking all over. What followed over the next 24 hours was a series of downgrades: first aid tent to ambulance to emergency room to hospital room to intensive care unit.

With each move, Donna’s doctors made reassuring noises, while privately sorting though alarming lab reports—like CK (creatine kinase) values that climbed from 9,000 to 123,000. Fortunately, massive doses of intravenous fluid prevented renal failure, though fluid collected in Donna’s lungs and around her heart, and one lobe in her lungs collapsed. Finally, the turn around came with a cut back on fluid. Donna began recovering.

Six weeks after the marathon, she was running again, but this time with a definite diagnosis. “My sister told them all about CPT deficiency. The doctors had never heard of it, but Aviva educated them a lot and they said yes, that sounds right. Then they got on the internet and looked for more information.”

In retrospect, Donna remembers episodes of muscle pain as early as age 16. She also believes the 1998 marathon left a permanent imprint. “If I skip breakfast and take the stairs, I can feel it in my legs more than I would have before. And I can’t run the way I used to. At most, now I go for an hour.”

But Donna still feels fortunate. “I see my sister who is affected on a weekly or monthly basis, while for me it takes something extreme.” As for marathons, Donna is philosophical. “It’s a mind change you have to go through,” she acknowledges. “You can still be in shape without running marathons. I know that now.”

Related links:
Phenotypic variability among first-degree relatives with carnitine palmitoyltransferase II deficiency  Abstract of a case history involving four sisters.

Carnitine palmitoyltransferase deficiency in a college athlete: a case report and literature review
Abstract of a case history reported in 1995 that compares CPT II deficiency with McArdle’s disease, another metabolic myopathy.

Acute muscle pain in an adolescent athlete
Abstract of another case of CPT II deficiency involving an 18-year-old female soccer player with incapacitating pain in both thighs, inability to walk, loss of bladder control and brown urine. 

How far can a person run?
Cool site built for Olympic athletes by the University of Montana. This link offers an animated diagram that allows you to choose one of four muscle fuels—fat, protein, carbohydrate and ATP-creatine phosphate—and then see how far the runner can go. 

Fueling the muscles
Great diagram on the MDA site that illustrates how muscles get fuel and what happens when a genetic defect roadblocks certain pathways.

IV or not IV? Only for grueling multi-day sports
Interesting article about the controversial practice of giving healthy but exhausted athletes IV treatments to aid recovery. 

Creatine kinase in energy metabolic signaling in muscle  10-page scientific paper from the Netherlands.


To read about more athletes with CPT deficiency, visit Same difference and Significant others.

To read about carbohydrate replacement after exercise, visit Damage control.

  

The release of CK has been studied in many exercise situations in which the individuals had some symptoms but recovered completely within a few days without treatment. Two different patterns of CK release and levels have emerged and these clearly relate to the type of exercise done: concentric or eccentric.
 
Creatine kinase (CK) levels are more elevated after eccentric exercise, though the elevation is delayed. Eccentric exercise causes more muscle stiffness, soreness, limb swelling, and loss of strength and range of motion. Muscle biopsies in these cases also show more disruption of contractile elements. 

Endurance athletes such as marathon runners have an increase in CK during their event, with a peak 24 hours later to levels of 2,500 to 5,000. Much of a runner’s exercise is concentric, whereas a bodybuilder doing mostly eccentric work will have CK elevation 2 days after exercise, with a peak at 5 to 6 days with levels of 100,000 to 200,000.
            --Rod Hamer, M.D.

   Home   Top   Back   Next
©  1999-2000 The Spiral Notebook    All Rights Reserved